Bang! was tonight's game that Isaac chose again, which I believe is a good choice for the family as a fun way to interact with everyone. Tonight, we got Janai to join us, even though she did spend most of the game practically refusing to heal her wounds.
Starting off the game, I was the Sheriff, and clockwise around the table was Grace, Beth, Janai, Isaac, and Anna. I didn't have any good clues of who was who the first round because no one shot at me, at least not directly. I think Indians came out and did hurt a couple people, but nothing to me. Also, Isaac's character gave him the ability to draw extra cards from being wounded, so he was happy to take some damage at first in order to grab a bunch of cards at the beginning of his next turn. Anna was the first to show her true colors, and shot me, with Isaac targeting me in the next round. Since we were using A Fistful Of Cards expansion for events, we had Abandoned Mine come up during a round when the Dynamite was being passed around the table, so it was interesting watching what was coming up for the next players and looking for opportunities to shift the next card to something more desirable for the person following you. At that point of the game, Grace seemed like she was doing everything to help me out, so I thought she was my Deputy, and some of Beth's plays made me think she was the Renegade. However, I found out that I was quite wrong when Grace played Indians at a time when I had only one card left in my hand and only one bullet (life point). I looked at Grace thinking, she must not realize what she's doing... and actually, she admitted afterward that she didn't think it was going to kill me. Resolving the Indians attack, Isaac was killed and revealed as an Outlaw, then I was killed and said, "We lost." Then she smiled and laughed and said, "But, I'm an Outlaw." ... "WHAT?" ... I couldn't believe it. Beth was my Deputy, and Janai was the Renegade. I had 3 of them completely mixed up since Grace had never attacked me directly. Well played, Grace. So, Grace, Anna, and Isaac (posthumously) won the game as the Outlaws.